CARDINAL SANTOS OF MANILA WAS CONSERVATIVE DURING VATICAN II BUT HE NEVER JOINED LEFEBVRE! HE REMAINED FAITHFUL AND LOYAL TO POPE PAUL VI UNTIL DEATH!
Yesterday, we commemorate the death anniversary of Cardinal Rufino Santos. But 𝐷𝐼𝐷 𝑌𝑂𝑈 𝐾𝑁𝑂𝑊? Cardinal Rufino Santos, the First Filipino Cardinal was a member of the conservative-wing of the Second Vatican Council.
During the Second Vatican Council, Cardinal Santos was one of the 49 bishops and archbishops from the Philippines to attend the council, He was a member of the conservative-wing of the Council known as the ‘Coetus Internationalis Patrum’ together with Archbishop Marcel Lefebvre (Superior CSSp) and 200+ other members, the group was the most important and influential interest group of the “conservative” or “traditionalist” minority at the Second Vatican Council.
According to Msgr. Moises Andrade, Cardinal Rufino Santos refused to abandon the Pre-Pauline Rite or Tridentine Mass and disapproved its celebration “ad popolo” even after the reforms of Vatican II. It was only during the 1970 Papal Visit of the late Pope Paul VI that he allowed the Novus Ordo Mass known then as the “People’s Mass” in deference to the Pope.
Sources:
—Kroeger, Fr. James (16 September 2012). “Great figures of Vatican II”. The Manila Times. Retrieved 23 October 2020.
— “Le Coetus Internationalis Patrum au concile Vatican II
—A Biography of Archbishop Marcel Lefebvre by Fr. Ramon Anglés
—Traditional Roman Catholic Philippines
RESPONSE:
Splendor1618
CARDINAL SANTOS DIDN’T JOIN LEFEBVRE. CARDINAL SANTOS AND CARDINAL OTTAVIANI LIVED AND DIED FAITHFUL TO ST. POPE PAUL VI. CARDINAL WOJTYLA AND THE POLISH BISHOPS WERE ALSO CONSERVATIVE DURING VATICAN II BUT THEY REMAINED FAITHFUL TO POPE ST. PAUL VI. UNLIKE LEFEBVRE WHO BECAME A REBEL AND A TRAITOR. SO HE WAS EXCOMMUNICATED. LEFEBVRE DIED EXCOMMUNICATED WHILE CARDINAL SANTOS, CARDINAL OTTAVIANI, VEN. FULTON J. SHEEN AND THE SUPER MAJORITY OF THE COUNCIL FATHERS REMAINED FAITHFUL TO THE POPE.
THERE IS A BIG DIFFERENCE BETWEEN A CONSERVATIVE FAITHFUL AND THAT OF A CONSERVATIVE TRAITOR! CARDINAL OTTAVIANI, CARDINAL SIRI, CARDINAL SANTOS, CARDINAL WOJTYLA AND THE OTHER CONSERVATIVES REMAINED FAITHFUL TO THE POPE!
THE REAL CONSERVATIVES IN VATICAN II LED BY OTTAVIANI AND CARDINAL SANTOS OBEYED THE POPE AND DIED FAITHFUL TO THE POPE. LEFEBVRE WAS SILENT DURING THE COUNCIL AND ONLY GATHERED DUST IN HIS SEAT. THEN BECAME DISOBEDIENT AFTER THE COUNCIL. LEFEBVRE EVEN SIGNED THE DOCUMENTS OF THE COUNCIL FOR APPROVAL BUT HE BECAME REBELLIOUS AGAINST HIS OWN SIGNED APPROVAL.
[According to Msgr. Moises Andrade, Cardinal Rufino Santos refused to abandon the Pre-Pauline Rite or Tridentine Mass and disapproved its celebration “ad popolo” even after the reforms of Vatican II. It was only during the 1970 Papal Visit of the late Pope Paul VI that he allowed the Novus Ordo Mass known then as the “People’s Mass” in deference to the Pope.]
THE POINT THERE IS NOT WHETHER CARDINAL SANTOS LIKED OR DISLIKED THE AD VERSUS POPULUM (FACING THE PEOPLE) WAY OF CELEBRATING THE MASS, BUT THE FACT THAT HE EVENTUALLY AND ULTIMATELY IMPLEMENTED THE MASS OF POPE ST. PAUL VI. HE DIDN’T IMPOSE HIS PERSONAL PREFERENCES OVER THAT OF THE FINAL DECISIONS OF THE HOLY FATHER.
NATURALLY, CARDINAL SANTOS WAS VERY OLD ALREADY DURING THE VATICAN II. THE HOLY SEE GAVE PROVISIONS FOR THOSE WHO ARE ALREADY VERY OLD OR SICKLY TO CONTINUE CELEBRATING THE TLM. SO PADRE PIO AND CARDINAL SANTOS CONTINUED CELEBRATING TLM BECAUSE OF OLD AGE BUT THEY NEVER JOINED LEFEBVRE. THEY REMAINED FAITHFUL TO THE POPE.
THE MASS OF POPE PAUL VI WAS OFFICIALLY APPROVED ONLY ON NOVEMBER 30, 1969 AND IT TOOK TIME TO FULLY IMPLEMENT IT. THE PAPAL VISIT WAS MADE FROM NOV 27-30, 1970 SO ONLY A YEAR AFTER THE PROMULGATION OF THE PAULINE MASS. NATURALLY, IT TOOK SEVERAL MONTHS BEFORE IT WAS PROPERLY IMPLEMENTED. EVEN WHEN THE ENGLISH TEXT OF THE PAULINE MASS WAS IMPLEMENTED UNDER POPE BENEDICT XVI IT TOOK MANY MONTHS BEFORE THE CHURCH OF THE PHILIPPINES CAN IMPLEMENT IT IN OUR ENGLISH MASSES. JUST THE PRINTING OF THE ROMAN MISSALS AND SACRAMENTARIES ALONE TOOK A LOT OF MONTHS TO FINISH. HOW MUCH MORE THE TRANSITION FROM TLM TO THE PAULINE MASS.
WHAT IS IMPORTANT IS THAT CARDINAL SANTOS DIDN’T DISOBEY OR DISRESPECT THE POPE. HE MADE IT SURE THAT WHEN THE POPE COMES FOR THE PAPAL VISIT THE NEW RITE OF THE MASS HAS BEEN PROPERLY CELEBRATED AS PROMULGATED BY ST. PAUL VI.
CARDINAL SANTOS DIED IN 1973 AND HE PASSED AWAY FAITHFULLY WITHOUT CREATING ANY ACT OF DISOBEDIENCE TO THE POPE.
References:
Splendor1618. (2022, September 8). CARDINAL SANTOS
OF MANILA WAS CONSERVATIVE DURING VATICAN II BUT HE NEVER JOINED LEFEBVRE! HE
REMAINED FAITHFUL AND LOYAL TO POPE PAUL VI UNTIL DEATH! Retrieved from
The Splendor of the Church:
https://thesplendorofthechurch.com/2022/09/08/cardinal-santos-of-manila-was-conservative-during-vatican-ii-but-he-never-joined-lefebvre-he-remained-faithful-and-loyal-to-pope-paul-vi-until-death/